
Inside this issue

Why Flow Computers?
Electronic flow computers play a vital role in the tracking of natural
gas and hydrocarbon liquids, as product ownership is transferred through
and between pipeline systems, across plant boundaries, in terminals
and at the wellhead.
In addition to bearing responsibility for the transfer system's fiscal
integrity, the flow computer must act as the "brain" of
an enhanced system that integrates numerous measurement, control,
sequencing, data logging and communication functions into a single
stand-alone device.
With all that's involved, the industry demands a highly secure, tamper-free,
reliable and accurate measurement device that will reduce the risk
of systematic errors or increased uncertainties. This has occurred
with some unsecured field programmable devices that are controlling
pumps, motors and compressors, to lose critical data or measurement
signals as a result of accidental resets or reprogramming of equipment.
|
Suppliers specializing in custody-transfer are integrating
many measurement, control, sequencing, data logging, and communication
functions into one device.
|
The flow computer's security regime should include multilevel keypad
and serial communication passwords, keylocks, totalizer error-checking,
redundant totalizer registers and configuration data, and maintenance
of calibration data even when firmware is changed.
Data archiving, alarm and configuration events, and stored reports
can provide months of backed-up data for audit retrieval. By having
on-line configuration access, the field technician or operator can
easily adjust his operating parameters without affecting program integrity.
This can be of critical importance when a variety of field instruments
can individually fail and a quick response is needed.
In custody-transfer applications, real-time, high-accuracy measurement
and control is being achieved. Because the flow computer is regarded
as the "cash register," it is imperative that it retain
or acquire the ability to seamlessly interface to devices such as
digital transmitters; turbine, ultrasonic, and coriolis mass meters;
viscometers; and densitometers.

NX-19 and AGA-8: The Difference
The American Gas Association Transmission Measurement Committee Report
No. 8, has made dramatic improvements over AGA Report NX-19. In 1962,
The American Gas Association (AGA) published a report (NX-19) developed
for calculations of supercompressibility factor of natural gases.
Because of the limited set of input parameters, and the limited accuracy
and applicability of previous AGA and ISO Standards, both GERG and
AGA provided new technically defensible Standards for the measurement
of Natural Gas.
These Standards established the most extensive empirical data base
(12,000 for AGA-8 vs. 300 for NX-19) ever developed in measurement
of gas. Additionally it established the tightest governor, for example,
on the equation performance ever developed. This governor dictates
that the equation performance by different flow computers must agree
within 50 ppm. This tolerance can be met only by performance of the
AGA report #3 and 8, 1992 revisions of the equations. AGA-3 uses new
techniques (equations) with consideration of Orifice and Pipe dimension
expansion from reference conditions based on temperature. Tolerance
for concentricity and structural dimensions tightly define manufacture
of measurement components.
AGA-8 sets specific accuracies associated with gas composition and
defines detailed methods of computing compressibility and density
for individual constituents. AGA Report No. 8 is dramatically more
accurate for high specific gravity and high carbon dioxide content
natural gases than NX-19.
| |
|
Percentage
Deviations |
| |
|
A.A.D.
% |
BIAS
% |
MAX
% |
Gas Classification
|
Specific Gravity |
NX-19 |
AGA
8 |
NX-19 |
AGA
8 |
NX-19 |
AGA
8 |
| Low Gravity |
0.60 |
0.096 |
0.044 |
-0.095 |
0.041 |
-0.232 |
0.189 |
| Moderate Gravity |
0.63 |
0.335 |
0.026 |
-0.335 |
0.015 |
-0.577 |
0.097 |
| High Gravity |
0.67 |
0.819 |
0.049 |
-0.819 |
0.021 |
-1.255 |
0.200 |
| Moderate Nitrogen |
0.66 |
0.066 |
0.067 |
0.066 |
0.065 |
0.141 |
0.120 |
| High Nitrogen |
0.78 |
0.158 |
0.056 |
0.158 |
0.038 |
0.233 |
0.125 |
| Moderate Carbon Dioxide |
0.71 |
0.114 |
0.027 |
-0.109 |
-0.010 |
-0.278 |
0.059 |
| High Carbon Dioxide |
0.87 |
0.606 |
0.079 |
-0.606 |
-0.079 |
-1.002 |
-0.134 |
Comparison of Computed Compressibility Factors for A.G.A. Reports
No. 8 and NX-19 with Experimental Compressibility Factors for Seven
Natural Gases. The average absolute percentage deviation (A.A.D.%)
the bias percentage deviation (BIAS%) and the maximum percentage deviation
(MAXD%) are referred to as their abbreviations.
With acknowledgments to Dr. K. Starling, Starling & Associates,
Norman, Oklahoma, for published data.

Coriolis Meters
Some coriolis Mass Meters can provide a density or viscosity measurement
in addition to a mass or volume measurement.
Most coriolis meters are used for liquid applications in process industries.
They have been popularized by not requiring any moving parts.
The coriolis force meter provides a direct measurement of the mass
flow rate of a fluid. Manufacturers claim that coriolis meter performance
is generally unaffected by changes in process temperature and pressure.
They can be advantageously used in place of conventional meters in
many applications where exposure to hazardous or corrosive chemicals
would be harmful to the operator, or when product conditions are not
well-known or unstable.
Coriolis meters are typically used where product flow is measured
or sold on a mass basis. However, some coriolis mass meters also provide
an on-line density measurement. Since volume at flowing conditions
is the ratio of Mass/Flowing Density, the mass meter can provide a
volumetric pulse output similar to a conventional volumetric meter.
But process conditions, fluid properties and mechanical system design
can affect individual meter performance. So, it may not be just a
simple choice between mass and volume.
There has been great interest in the use of these flow meters in oil
production, transportation and marketing applications. Their use has
been approved by various Weights & Measures agencies. API and
IP in UK have produced technical papers for the guidance of users.
An acceptable API standard for the use of these devices has not yet
emerged due to the absence of sufficient user field data from metering
systems with varied operating pipeline and process conditions.
Omni flow computers already have the necessary firmware to receive
both pulse and RS485 communication from Micro Motion transmitters.
Omnis can provide selectable mass or volumetric metering and proving
with Micro Motion meters, the leader in mass meter installations within
the energy industry. Applications at locations as far apart as Thailand,
Colombia and Siberia are using Omnis with Micro Motion meters. Omni
has also received NMi Approval (Weights & Measures, Holland) for
interface to the Rheonik mass meter.
Smart Transmitters
Digital transmitters have the ability to provide more than one measurement
variable at a time, resulting in reduced costs and improved accuracy.
Digital (a.k.a. "smart") transmitter technology has been
available in flow-related devices for at least a decade. The ability
to integrate field measurement into process control systems on a more
cost-effective basis is a growing requirement around the world.
Improved measurement accuracy and ease of reliable calibration is
a constant goal in a technologically-challenged world that has been
used to the 4-20 mA signal standard. Most field transmitters, utilizing
capacitance and resistance, communicate with the flow computer via
4-20 mA signal. However, only a limited amount of information (i.e.
the measured variable) can be represented by a single 4-20 mA signal.
A major benefit of a digital transmitter is the ability to provide
more than one measurement variable at a time. Digital communication
can significantly reduce the costs of separately connecting multiple
measurement devices into a distributed process control system.
Smart transmitters improve accuracy by eliminating analog to digital
conversions by communicating a direct digital signal. But digital
protocols can also take time to send all the process information to
the host system. The delay can be more than one second. This can cause
a greater measurement uncertainty and may provide little or no gain
over the 4-20mA signal.
For example, in an Omni, the process input comes in as a continuously
monitored frequency and not as a sampling A/D. Because operational
features, such as PID, need fast updates, the Omni expects to use
that process value every 500 msec.
The major obstacles to acceptance of digital transmitters and the
proprietary digital protocols being used by individual manufacturers
are the absence of a common standard and sufficiently skilled field
technicians in various world markets who can adapt to changing calibration
requirements and new technologies.
A common standard would ensure the development of open architecture
systems. A common industry standard such as the one for analog transmitters,
would ensure that any product from any manufacturer can work together
safely and reliably with any other device. The new digital standard
being developed is known as Fieldbus.
Omni flow computers can accept RS485 Modbus from Fisher-Rosemount
3095 Multi-Variable Transmitters; and from the Honeywell ST3000 series
of transmitters using Honeywell's DE protocol. Omni’s built-in
modularity allows Omni to be both Fieldbus-ready and technologically
ready for any other advancements without obsoleting the "cashregister"!
|
|